National Geographic has just published an article that sets the record straight on the nature of the ancient Neanderthals. In so doing, it contradicts what it published in February, 1916–a commentary by former president Theodore Roosevelt, no less.
Roosevelt wrote: “These Neanderthal men were squat, burly, big-headed, thick-skulled savages, with brows projecting over cavernous eyes, knees permanently bent, and jaws almost chinless. Their brains were of good size, but the portions which represent the higher intellectual attainments were poorly developed.”
Paleoartist Charles R. Knight added two illustrations to Roosevelt’s piece. One showed two brutish hunched-over Neanderthal cavemen dressed in loinclothes and possessing a wooden club. The other picture displays two modern looking Cro-magnon men painting on a cave wall by the light of an oil lamp.
Neanderthals have been insulted ever since their fossils were first found in a quarry in the Neander Valley in Germany 170 years ago. At first, their bones were thought to be those of a cave bear or a deformed soldier or of a wild race of men. This was before Darwin’s theory of evolution was proposed.
Later, in 1864, geologist William King evaluated the bones in light of evolution and formally named them Homo neanderthalensis. It was the first time scientists had discovered evidence of an extinct human species, or so they thought. King called the Neanderthal a brute. Then a couple of years later, German zoologist Ernst Haeckel was more blunt, calling the Neanderthal “Homo stupidus.” Then French paleontologist Marcellin Boucle concluded that the creature was more ape than human.
Famed science fiction writer H. G. Wells didn’t help the reputation of Neanderthals either. In his book The Outline of History and short story, The Grisly Folk, he referred to Neanderthals as ugly, inarticulate, lumbering idiots who would be vanquished by real humans.
Now the views of Neanderthals have dramatically changed. “Every day, there’s some new discovery about Neanderthals showing how smart they were,” says Ian Tattersall, curator emeritus of human origins at the American Museum of Natural History in New York. “What I think they show us is that it is possible to be incredibly intelligent and not be Homo sapiens. And that we Homo sapiens are astonishingly egotistical in thinking that our way of being smart is the only way of being smart.”
Archaeological clues from scattered sites suggest that some Neanderthals may have buried their dead, practiced rudimentary dentistry, hunted birds at night, managed hearths, manufactured red ocher, constructed structures from cave stalagmites, likely painted cave art, and more. Neanderthals may have even had compassion for each other based on evidence that they cared for their elderly and disabled and even a child who likely had Downs syndrome. Such empathy or altruism was thought to be a human-only characteristic, according to Genevieve von Petzinger, a paleoanthropologist.
Then there is DNA. Neanderthal DNA still exists in modern humans. In 2010 their DNA was sequenced and found to be 99.7 identical to that of modern humans. Homo sapiens and Neanderthals interbred for a long time.
Comments: Dictionary com defines a species as “1. Biology A group of closely related organisms that are very similar to each other and are usually capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring.” Now that we know Neanderthals and other humans successfully interbred, is there still any reason they are still being referred to as Homo neanderthalensis?
But apparently most evolutionist scientists still want to hold on to Homo neanderthalensis in order to make the Neanderthals seem like a distinct species. Even an alternate designation which has been used, Homo sapiens neanderthalensis, apparently isn’t good enough for most of them.
But based on what we now know about them, what is there about the Neanderthals that sets them apart from us. Sure, they may have looked different from modern humans just as various groups of modern humans today look different from each other. But clearly they were 100% humans.
Swedish biologist Svante Pääbo, who led a team of scientists which studied the Neanderthal genome said, “Many would say that a species is a group of organisms that can produce fertile offspring with each other and cannot do so with members of other groups. From that perspective we had shown that Neanderthals and modern humans were the same species.”
Like all of us humans, Neanderthals descended from Noah’s family and were scattered after the Tower of Babel incident. If somehow they had heard and believed the promise of a Messiah, they will be with us in heaven.
It isn’t what we look like on the outside that makes us a Christian. It is what we believe in our hearts.
“Certainly, if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved,” Romans 10:9.
Reference: Nicholas St. Fleur, "Justice for Neanderthals!" National Geographic [October 9, 2026].
**************************************
Want to be automatically notified each time there is a new post? Just email your request to wkrug@lutheranscience.org.
****************************************
NOTE ON VISITOR COMMENTS: Visitor comments are invited including those containing alternate views. However, comments containing profanity, personal attacks or advertisements will not be published. After posting a comment, please allow several hours for it to appear on the blog.

No comments:
Post a Comment